Journal of South China University of Technology(Natural Science Edition)

• Traffic & Transportation Engineering • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Modeling the Severity of Commercial Vehicle Accidents Considering Unobserved Heterogeneity

LIU Zhenghua1,2  GUO Peixin3  WANG Shoudong1,2  ZHANG Yue4  DONG Chunjiao3  XIONG Zhihua3   

  1. 1. Transport planning and Research Institute Ministry of Transport, Beijing 100028, China

    2. Laboratory of Transport Safety and Emergency Technology, Beijing 100028, China

    3. Key Laboratory of Transport Industry of Big Data Application Technologies for Comprehensive Transport, Ministry of Transport, Beijing Jiaotong University, Beijing 100044, China

    4. Yunnan Qujing Comprehensive Administrative Law Enforcement Detachment of Transportation, Qujing 655000

  • Published:2025-10-17

Abstract:

With the rapid development of the road transport industry, the number of accidents involving operational vehicles has been continuously increasing, and the severity of these accidents has become a widespread concern. Especially, operational vehicles, due to their unique operational characteristics, face more complex traffic environments and risks. This study analyzes the impact of "unobserved heterogeneity" on the severity of operational vehicle accidents. Based on traffic accident data for operational buses and trucks in China, relevant variables are selected from four aspects: driver behavior, vehicle type, road characteristics, and environmental conditions, and a random parameters Logit model is constructed. By introducing random parameters, the model can effectively capture heterogeneity and uncertainty between individuals, improving its explanatory power and predictive performance. The SHAP method is further applied to analyze the direction, importance, and non-linear interactions between variables. The results show that, for operational buses, complex road shapes and vehicle types significantly increase the severity of accidents, especially the interaction effect between complex road conditions and improper operations, which notably raises the accident severity. For operational trucks, the interaction effect between hazardous material transport vehicles and complex road conditions is stronger, and speeding behavior significantly increases the probability of major accidents. The SHAP analysis quantifies the contribution of 10 multidimensional factors to accident severity, revealing that bus accidents are mainly influenced by road environment factors, while truck accidents are more significantly related to vehicle attributes. This further quantifies the differing impacts of human factors and environmental factors on the severity of accidents.

Key words: operational vehicle safety, severity causality analysis, unobserved heterogeneity, random parameter Logit model, SHAP interpretability analysis