Commutation Failure Detection Based on Temporal Feature of AC Maximum Current on the Valve-Side

doi:10.12141/j.issn.1000-565X.210810

Abstract

Abstract:

Commutation failure (CF) is common for the operation of HVDC transmission system, and it reflects the vulnerability of converter. The existing methods for judging CF are subject to influence of fault factors and control adjustments, resulting in the insufficient sensitivity of the methods. Accurate and reliable detection of CF is extremely important to control and protection. Therefore, the paper proposed a detection scheme for CF based on temporal feature of AC maximum current on the valve-side starting from detecting the valve conduction interval. Firstly, the characteristics of AC maximum current was constructed based on the ratio between the unilaterally polarity current of AC current on the converter terminal and the half of the maximum value of the three-phase AC current. Secondly, to reduce the impact of operating conditions, taking the current intersection of two commutating valves currents as the demarcation point, the virtual conducting state of the valve was constructed by using half of the amplitude of the characteristic quantity of AC maximum current, and the accumulated width was calculated by integrating it in a period to determine whether the virtual conducting state of the valve is abnormal.Then, the interlocking relationship between the lengthened and shortened virtual conduction width was used to determine the commutation failure during the commutation process. According to the analysis of power disturbance, fault transiency and the sampling step, the threshold for commutation failure was derived. The recommended threshold value is 1.3 millisecond. Finally, based on the PSCAD / EMTDC electromagnetic transient simulation and wave recorded data, the results show that the proposed detection method is reliable to detect commutation failure. Compared with the detection method based on differential current, the proposed method for detecting commutation failure is less affected by factors, such as operating conditions of AC and DC system, fault moment, and fault severity under different fault conditions. This proposed method can locate the valve of commutation failure and provides more margin for the adjustment of the control system.

Key words: LCC-HVDC, commutation, valve-side current, valve conducting state, temporal feature

CLC Number:

TM772

LI Xiaohua, YIN Shanshan, LI Jiewen, et al. Commutation Failure Detection Based on Temporal Feature of AC Maximum Current on the Valve-Side[J]. Journal of South China University of Technology(Natural Science Edition), 2022, 50(7): 108-117.

Figures/Tables 14

Fig.1

Fig.2

Fig.3

Fig.4

Fig.5

Fig.6

Fig.7

Fig.8

Table 1

Influence of fault types on the detection scheme of valve conducting state"

FT	$t c f ? / m s$	$m$	$t c s ? / m s$	$Z H m$	$Δ t Z 1 ? / m s$
单相（a相）接地故障（AG）	5.5	1	16.1	2	0.3
		2	16.0	0
		3	18.7	0
		4	5.8	2
		5	23.1	0
		6	5.8	0
两相（ab两相）接地故障（ABG）	2.2	1	9.2	0	0.3
		2	14.0	0
		3	2.5	2
		4	5.9	2
		5	2.5	0
		6	5.8	0
三相故障（ABC）	2.2	1	9.2	0	0.3
		2	18.0	2
		3	2.5	2
		4	5.9	2
		5	2.5	0
		6	5.8	0
相间（ab两相）故障（AB）	2.1	1	9.2	0	0.4
		2	12.8	0
		3	2.5	2
		4	5.9	2
		5	2.5	0
		6	5.8	0

Table 1

Table 2

Influence of DC power on two detection schemes"

P*（p.u.）	$t c f ? / m s$	$t c s 1 ? / m s$	$t c s 2 ? / m s$	$Δ t Z 1 ? / m s$	$Δ t Z 2 ? / m s$
1.0	5.5	5.8	12.1	0.3	6.6
0.8	5.4	5.8	10.3	0.4	4.9
0.5	5.0	5.4	10.7	0.4	5.7
0.3	4.7	5.0	12.1	0.3	7.4

Table 2

Table 3

Influence of fault resistance on two detection schemes"

$r F ? / Ω$	$t c f ? / m s$	$t c s 1 ? / m s$	$t c s 2 ? / m s$	$Δ t Z 1 ? / m s$	$Δ t Z 2 ? / m s$
0.5	5.5	5.8	12.1	0.3	6.6
1.0	5.5	5.8	12.1	0.3	6.6
3.0	5.7	5.8	11.5	0.1	5.8
5.0	7.3	7.6	11.6	0.3	4.3
8.0	8.4	8.6	11.6	0.2	3.1

Table 3

Table 4

Influence of initial fault angle on two detection schemes"

$A F / (°)$	$t c f ? / m s$	$t c s 1 ? / m s$	$t c s 2 ? / m s$	$Δ t Z 1 ? / m s$	$Δ t Z 2 ? / m s$
0	5.5	5.8	12.1	0.3	6.6
30	3.7	4.1	10.4	0.4	6.7
60	2.1	2.4	4.2	0.3	2.1
90	2.1	2.4	7.9	0.3	5.5
120	8.7	9.2	13.4	0.5	4.7
150	7.0	7.4	11.7	0.4	4.4
180	5.5	5.8	12.1	0.3	6.6

Table 4

Fig.9

Fig.10

References 21

1	SONG J Z， LI Y L， ZHANG Y K ．The infl‍uence of open-phase operation of inverter side AC subsystem on commutation process and countermeasures［J］．International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems，2021，129：106805．
2	宋金钊，李永丽，曾亮，等．高压直流输电系统换相失败研究综述［J］．电力系统自动化，2020，44（22）：2-13.
	SONG Jinzhao， LI Yongli， ZENG Liang，et al ．Review on commutation failure of HVDC transmission system［J］，Automation of Electric Power Systems，2020，44（22）：2-13.
3	陈德扬，罗炜，郭琦，等．常规直流阀区故障与测量隐患定位方法［J］．电力系统自动化，2021，45（12）：167-173．
	CHEN Deyang， LUO Wei， GUO Qi，et al ．Location method of fault and hidden measurement defect for LCC HVDC valve area［J］．Automation of Electric Power Systems，2021，45（12）：167-173．
4	YANG H H， CAI Z X， LI X H，et al ．Assessment of commutation failure in HVDC systems considering spatial-temporal discreteness of AC system faults［J］．Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy，2018，6（5）：1055-1065.
5	YIN S S， LI X H， LI J W，et al ．Real-time virtual measurement technique for the thyristor valve current based on the converter terminal current［J］．IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery，10.1109/TPWRD.2021.3129060/1-11.
6	WEI Z H， FANG W L， LIU J ．A criterion for accurate identification of commutation failure in HVDC［J］．Electric Power Systems Research，2020，184：106338/1-12.
7	田庆，潘本仁，李正天，等．交直流控制保护功能配合方案研究［J］．电力科学与技术学报，2016，31（2）：22-30.
	TIAN Qing， PAN Benren， LI Zhengtian，et al ．Research on coordination method for the alternating current and direct current control & protection［J］．Journal of Electric Power Science and Technology，2016，31（2）：22-30.
8	MARVASTI F， MIRZAEI A ．A novel method of combined DC and harmonic overcurrent protection for rectifier converters of monopolar HVDC systems［J］．IEEE Transaction on Power Delivery，2018，33（2）：892-900.
9	李佳曼，蔡泽祥，李晓华，等．直流系统保护对交流故障的响应机理与交流故障引发的直流系统保护误动分析［J］．电网技术，2015，39（4）：953-960.
	LI Jiaman， CAI Zexiang， LI Xiaohua，et al ．Response mechanism of UHVDC system protection to faults in UHVDC system and analysis on malfunction of UHVDC protection caused by faults in UHVDC system［J］．Power System Technology，2015，39（4）：953-960.
10	束洪春，王璇，田鑫萃，等．交流故障下永富直流换流器差动保护误动风险分析［J］．高电压技术，2018，44（2）：478-487.
	SHU Hongchun， WANG Xuan， TIAN Xincui，et al ．Mal-operation risk analysis of Yongfu DC converter differential protection under AC fault［J］．High Voltage Engineering，2018，44（2）：478-487.
11	王增平，刘席洋，郑博文，等．基于电压波形拟合的换相失败快速预测与抑制措施［J］．电工技术学报，2020，35（7）：1454-1463.
	WANG Zengping， LIU Xiyang， ZHENG Bowen，et al ．The research on fast prediction and suppression measures of commutation failure based on voltage waveform fitting［J］．Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society，2020，35（7）：1454-1463.
12	申洪明，黄少锋，费彬，等．基于数学形态学的换相失败检测新方法［J］．电工技术学报，2016，31（4）：170-177.
	SHEN Hongming， HUANG Shaofeng， FEI Bin， et al ．A new method to detect commutation failure based on mathematical morphology［J］．Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society，2016，31（4）：170-177.
13	陈光侵，傅闯，张勇军．基于阀侧电流特征的高压直流换相失败检测方法［J］．电网技术，2019，43（10）：3488-3496.
	CHEN Guangqin， FU Chuang， ZHANG Yongjun ．Detection method of HVDC CF based on characteristics of valve-side current［J］．Power System Technology，2019，43（10）：3488-3496.
14	李轩，梅飞，沙浩源，等．考虑样本不平衡的特高压换流阀状态评估及其影响因素分析［J］．中国电机工程学报，2022，42（4）：1558-1569.
	LI Xuan， MEI Fei， SHA Haoyuan，et al ．State evaluation of UHVDC converter valve considering sample imbalance and its influencing factors analysis［J］．Proceedings of the CSEE，2022，42（4）：1558-1569.
15	陈光侵，傅闯，张勇军．基于阀电流特征的高压直流换相失败检测方法［J］．电力系统自动化，2018，42（23）：86-94，119.
	CHEN Guangqin， FU Chuang， ZHANG Yongjun ．Detection method of HVDC communication failure based on characteristic of valve current［J］．Automation of Electric Power Systems，2018，42（23）：86-94，119.
16	邹亮，刘涛，赵彤，等．基于阀电压或阀电流的HVDC换相失败故障诊断［J］．电网技术，2014，38（12）：3453-3458.
	ZOU Liang， LIU Tao， ZHAO Tong，et al ．Diagnosis of commutation failure in HVDC transmission systems based on voltage or current of converter valve［J］．Power System Technology，2014，38（12）：3453-3458.
17	李欣蔚，刘崇茹，韩玉蓉，等．送端系统对交直流系统输送功率极限的影响［J］．电力系统自动化，2017，41（17）：101-105，141.
	LI Xinwei， LIU Chongru， HAN Yurong，et al ．Effect of sending-end system on maximum transmission power of AC/DC system［J］．Automation of Electric Power Systems，2017，41（17）：101-105，141.
18	罗汉武，乐健，毛涛，等．扎鲁特—青州±800 kV特高压直流输电工程运行特性分析［J］．电力自动化设备，2019，39（1）：53-59.
	LUO Hanwu， LE Jian， MAO Tao，et al ．Analysis of operation characteristics of Zhalute-Qingzhou ±800 kV UHVDC system［J］．Electric Power Automation Equipment，2019，39（1）：53-59.
19	欧开健，任震，荆勇．直流输电系统换相失败的研究（一）—换相失败的影响因素分析［J］．电力自动化设备，2003，23（5）：5-9.
	Kaijian OU， REN Zhen， JING Yong ．Research on commutation failure in HVDC transmission system part1：commutation failure factors analysis［J］．Electric Power Automation Equipment，2003，23（5）：5-9.
20	SHAO Y， TANG Y ．Fast evaluation of commutation failure risk in multi-infeed HVDC systems［J］．IEEE Transaction Power Systems，2018，33（1）：646-653.
21	吴秋媚，傅闯，龚英明，等．3种高压直流同步触发控制的对比分析［J］．电网技术，2020，44（12）：4744-4754.
	WU Qiumei， FU Chuang， GONG Yingming，et al ．Comparative analysis of three kinds of HVDC synchronous firing control systems［J］．Power System Technology，2020，44（12）：4744-4754.

[1]	HU Yongjian, ZHUO Sichao, LIU Beibei, WANG Yufei, LI Jicheng. Improvement of Cross-Dataset Performance of Face Forgery Detection Based on Multi-Scale Spatiotemporal Features and Tampering Probabilities [J]. Journal of South China University of Technology(Natural Science Edition), 2024, 52(6): 110-119.
[2]	LI Jiachun, LI Bowen, LIN Weiwei. AdfNet: An Adaptive Deep Forgery Detection Network Based on Diverse Features [J]. Journal of South China University of Technology(Natural Science Edition), 2023, 51(9): 82-89.
[3]	LIU Xiaolei, DUAN Zhengyu, YU Qing, et al. Passenger Flow Forecast of Urban Rail Transit Based on Graph Convolution and Recurrent Neural Network [J]. Journal of South China University of Technology(Natural Science Edition), 2022, 50(3): 21-27.
[4]	ZHU Jia ZUO Jian LI Yinhong. Commutation Failure Suppression Strategy Based on Multi-Angle Prediction in Hybrid Dual-Infeed HVDC System [J]. Journal of South China University of Technology (Natural Science Edition), 2018, 46(10): 24-31.
[5]	CAI Ze-xiang YANG Huan-huan YU Chao-yun LI Xiao-hua. A Method to Assess Commutation Failure of HVDC Systems Taking Space-Time Discreteness into Consideration [J]. Journal of South China University of Technology (Natural Science Edition), 2017, 45(7): 33-40.
[6]	Zhang yao Lin Ling-xue Zhong Qing. Fault Diagnosis Based on Wavelet for Commutation Failures in HVDC [J]. Journal of South China University of Technology (Natural Science Edition), 2007, 35(10): 172-177.