Vehicle Engineering

Application of Subjective and Objective Comprehensive Evaluation Method of Drivability in Starting Conditions

  • WU Fei ,
  • SUN Xiankui ,
  • WANG Pengcheng
Expand
  • School of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering,Wuhan University of Technology,Wuhan 430070,Hubei,China

Received date: 2024-05-22

  Online published: 2024-10-29

Supported by

the National Natural Science Foundation of China(52275505)

Abstract

To improve the accuracy and reliability of the drivability evaluation method,this study proposed a subjective and objective comprehensive evaluation method integrating the Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) algorithm, the Sparrow Search Algorithm (SSA) and the Shapley Additive Explanations (SHAP). Focusing on vehicle starting conditions, the study defined nine objective evaluation indicators to refine the drivability assessment system for vehicle start-up performance. A bidirectional mapping model between objective metrics and subjective scores was established using the XGBoost algorithm. To avoid local optima in the drivability evaluation model, the SSA was employed to efficiently optimize the core hyperparameters of XGBoost, thereby enabling the model to iteratively self-improve as the dataset expands. Finally, the SHAP was used to attribute the features of the mapping model, quantify the influence weight of objective evaluation indicators on the evaluation of drivability, and construct a comprehensive evaluation model of drivability with prediction accuracy, stability and interpretability. The proposed method was validated through multiple road tests that incorporate both domestic and international mainstream drivability evaluation frameworks. Comparative analysis shows that the proposed model outperforms mainstream approaches such as BP neural networks, random forests, and extreme learning machines (ELMs) in terms of MAE (Mean Absolute Error), RMSE (Root Mean Square Error), and the coefficient of determination. The mapping accuracy is significantly improved, and the method’s interpretability makes it a valuable reference for integrating subjective and objective assessments in drivability evaluation.

Cite this article

WU Fei , SUN Xiankui , WANG Pengcheng . Application of Subjective and Objective Comprehensive Evaluation Method of Drivability in Starting Conditions[J]. Journal of South China University of Technology(Natural Science), 2025 , 53(6) : 66 -76 . DOI: 10.12141/j.issn.1000-565X.240243

References

1 SCHMIEDT M, HE P, RINDERKNECHT S .Target state optimization:drivability improvement for vehicles with dual clutch transmissions[J].Applied Sciences-Basel202212(20):1-30.
2 边扬,俞洁,赵晓华,等 .导航播报措辞对驾驶行为的综合影响研究[J].华南理工大学学报(自然科学版)202048(11):30-37,54.
  BIAN Yang, YU Jie, ZHAO Xiaohua,et al .Research on the comprehensive influence of navigation broadcast wording on driving behavior[J].Journal of South China University of Technology (Natural Science Edition)202048(11):30-37,54.
3 LIU P H, ZHANG T, ZHAO X B .Vehicle drivability evaluation and pedal-acceleration response analysis [J].International Journal on Advances in Information Sciences and Service Sciences20135:506-513.
4 WI H, PARK J, LEE J .The influence of noise in vehicles on the driver’s subjective evaluation of driveability [J].Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part D:Journal of Automobile Engineering2018232(11):1494-1500.
5 林彦名,蒋贤芳,蒋华梁 .基于驾驶性主观评价和AVL-Drive客观测试的整车驾驶性主客观评价方法 [J].时代汽车2022(21):13-15.
  LIN Yanming, JIANG Xianfang, JIANG Hualiang .Subjective and objective evaluation method of vehicle drivability based on subjective evaluation of drivability and objective test of AVL-Drive[J].Auto Time2022(21):13-15.
6 吴文文,陈帅 .插电式混合动力汽车驾驶性主观评价方法[J].汽车实用技术202348(19):127-132.
  WU Wenwen, CHEN Shuai .Subjective evaluation methods of driving performance for plug-in hybrid electric vehicles[J].Automobile Applied Technology202348(19):127-132.
7 张宸维,林方圆 .电动汽车驾驶性主观评价研究 [J].汽车实用技术2019(18):8-11.
  ZHANG Chenwei, LIN Fangyuan .Subjective evaluation research of drivability of pure electric vehicle[J].Automobile Applied Technology2019(18):8-11.
8 逯家鹏,杨雪峰,张丽雪,等 .用户常用加速工况车辆驾驶性客观评价指标的设定与试验研究[J].汽车技术2022(6):40-46.
  LU Jiapeng, YANG Xuefeng, ZHANG Lixue,et al .Research on drivability objective index setting and test on cceleration condition in common use[J].Automobile Technology2022(6):40-46.
9 朱翔宇 .车辆起步加速驾驶性客观评价及优化[J].汽车工程学报202212(1):47-54.
  ZHU Xiangyu .Objective evaluation and optimization of vehicle starting performance[J].Chinese Journal of Automotive Engineering202212(1):47-54.
10 SHIN C W, KIM H, KIM M K,et al .Development of an evaluation method for quantitative driveability in heavy-duty vehicles (Article)[J].Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology201428(5):1615-1621.
11 SCHOEGGL P, RAMSCHAK E .Vehicle driveability assessment using neural networks for development,calibration and quality tests[J].SAE Transactions2000109(6):1052-1061.
12 李立治 .混合动力汽车驾驶性研究[D].天津:河北工业大学,2022.
13 李波 .基于底盘测功机的整车驾驶性客观测试与评价方法研究[D].合肥:合肥工业大学,2023.
14 莫易敏,胡恒,王骏,等 .基于神经网络的车辆急加速工况驾驶性评价研究[J].汽车技术2021(4):12-18.
  MO Yimin, HU Heng, WANG Jun,et al .Research on driveability evaluation of vehicles on tip-in condition based on neural network[J].Automobile Technology2021(4):12-18.
15 HUANG W, LIU H J, MA Y F .Drivability evaluation model using principal component analysis and optimized extreme learning machine[J].Journal of Vibration and Control201925(16):2274-2281.
16 徐福来 .汽车驾驶性能的评估方法研究 [D].长春:吉林大学,2023.
17 宋世欣,张元侠,刘科,等 .双离合器自动变速器控制品质评价指标分析[J].汽车工程201537(8):925-930.
  SONG Shixin, ZHANG Yuanxia, LIU Ke,et al .Analysis on the evaluation metrics of control quality for vehicles with dual clutch transmission[J].Automotive Engineering201537(8):925-930.
18 BENTéJAC C, CS?RG? A, MARTíNEZ-MU?OZ G .A comparative analysis of gradient boosting algorithms[J].Artificial Intelligence Review202154(3):1937-1967.
19 VIMBI V, SHAFFI N, MAHMUD M .Interpreting artificial intelligence models:a systematic review on the application of LIME and SHAP in Alzheimer’s disease detection[J].Brain Informatics202411:10/1-29.
Outlines

/